Should you consolidate your card debt into a loan?

Compare grinding through credit card minimum payments against a fixed personal loan or HELOC. See the total interest and payoff time, side by side.

Run the numbers

$
%
%
Loan term

Consolidating saves you in interest

Loan payment: —
Card interest: —
Loan interest: —

A snapshot, not the whole story

This calculator assumes you stop using the cards and never add new debt. In real life, balances move every month and it's easy to run the cards back up after consolidating. The Pay Down app tracks your actual balances across every card so you can see whether the consolidation is still working — or whether the debt is quietly creeping back.

Your debt changes every month — the app tracks it automatically

A calculator gives you a snapshot. Pay Down connects to your bank and keeps the math current as your balances, statements, and due dates change.

  • Connects to your bank via Plaid — balances always up to date
  • Recalculates your true payoff date after every statement
  • Tracks your progress and alerts you when due dates approach
Get it on Google Play iOS coming soon

Understanding debt consolidation

Why a fixed loan beats minimum payments

The reason credit card debt is so sticky isn't just the high APR — it's the structure of the minimum payment. Minimums are a small percentage of your balance, so as the balance falls, the payment falls too. That keeps you in debt far longer than the rate alone would suggest. A balance that feels manageable at $200 a month can take decades to clear when the payment keeps shrinking.

A consolidation loan flips that. You borrow a fixed amount, at a fixed rate, repaid over a fixed term — and the payment never shrinks. That single structural change forces the balance to zero on a schedule, and because the rate is usually lower, you pay far less interest along the way.

Personal loan vs. HELOC

Two common consolidation tools work differently. A personal loan is unsecured: no collateral, a fixed rate, and a fixed term, usually two to five years. A HELOC — home equity line of credit — is secured by your house. That security usually buys a lower rate, but it comes with real risk: miss payments and your home is on the line. HELOCs are also often variable-rate, so the number can move on you.

This calculator works for either. Enter the APR and term you've actually been quoted, and compare the total interest against your cards. Just remember the calculator can't price in the risk of putting your home up as collateral — that's a judgment only you can make.

Consolidation doesn't erase debt — it restructures it. The win comes from a lower rate and a payment that actually finishes the job.

The catch nobody mentions

Consolidation has a behavioral trap. Once your cards are paid off by the loan, they're sitting there with a zero balance and full available credit. The single biggest reason consolidation fails is that people run the cards back up — and now they have a loan payment plus new card debt. The math in this calculator only works if you stop adding to the cards.

That's exactly the kind of drift the Pay Down app is built to catch. It tracks every card balance continuously, so if the debt starts creeping back after you consolidate, you'll see it long before it becomes a problem again.

Try our other free calculators

Frequently asked questions

Does consolidating credit card debt into a loan save money?

It saves money when the loan's APR is meaningfully lower than your card APR and you stick to the fixed payment. A personal loan or HELOC at 9% replacing cards at 22% can cut total interest dramatically — and a fixed term forces the balance to zero on a schedule, unlike shrinking card minimums that can stretch for decades.

What's the difference between a HELOC and a personal loan for consolidation?

A personal loan is unsecured and has a fixed rate and term. A HELOC is secured by your home, usually carries a lower rate, but puts your house at risk if you can't pay and often has a variable rate. Both can consolidate card debt; this calculator works for either — just enter the APR and term you've been quoted.

Why do card minimum payments take so long?

Minimum payments are calculated as a small percentage of your balance, so as the balance shrinks, so does the payment. That stretches payoff for years and piles up interest. A consolidation loan replaces that with a fixed payment that actually retires the debt on a set date.

What loan term should I choose?

A shorter term means a higher monthly payment but less total interest; a longer term lowers the payment but costs more overall. Try each term in the calculator to see the trade-off between monthly affordability and total interest paid.

How is this different from the Pay Down app?

This calculator compares one consolidation scenario at a single moment. The Pay Down app tracks your actual card balances across every card, recalculates payoff projections as your balances change, and helps you decide between consolidation, avalanche, and snowball strategies with real numbers.